The UK demanded that Apple grant access to encrypted data: the court has upheld the secret order

A London court has authorised the official disclosure of the existence of a government request to Apple. The company is challenging the order, and a ruling on its legality is expected in 2027.

0

In the UK, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed on 19 November 2026 that the government had issued a secret order to Apple requiring access to users’ encrypted data. The court rejected the Home Office’s arguments that even confirming the existence of the order would jeopardise national security. Apple is challenging the order, and a final ruling on its legality is not expected until 2027 at the earliest.

Key points at a glance:

  • On 19 November, a British court confirmed the existence of a secret government order issued to Apple.
  • The directive concerns the technical capability to access the company’s protected customer data.
  • Apple is challenging the demand, whilst human rights campaigners are speaking out against any weakening of encryption and the secrecy surrounding such orders.
  • The court has not yet ruled on the legality of the order. The main hearing is expected to take place in 2027.

What did the British court rule in the Apple case?

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal in London has established that the British Home Office did indeed send Apple the so-called Technical Capability Notice (TCN).

This mechanism is provided for under the UK Investigatory Powers Act 2016. It allows the government to require technology companies to provide technical means of accessing certain data within the scope of the powers of law enforcement agencies and the security services.

Pending the court’s decision, the government had adopted a policy of neither confirming nor denying the existence of such an order. The authorities explained this by the need to safeguard national security.

However, the judges concluded that information about the order had already been so widely discussed in public that official confirmation of its existence posed virtually no additional threat.

This is recorded in the official court ruling of 19 November 2026.

Why is the UK demanding access to iCloud data?

Add UkrMedia to your Google sources Get more of our news in the recommendations.

The dispute centres on the protection of information in the iCloud cloud service, specifically the Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature.

It provides end-to-end encryption for additional categories of data, including device backups, photographs and notes. With this level of protection, the decryption keys are controlled by the user’s devices, and Apple itself does not have the technical capability to read this information.

In January 2025, the British authorities issued an initial demand which, according to media reports, covered users’ encrypted backups both in United Kingdom, as well as in the US.

Following talks with Washington, this order was withdrawn. However, London subsequently issued a new directive which, according to Reuters, applies only to British Apple users.

In February 2025, the company stopped offering Advanced Data Protection to new users in the UK and subsequently disabled the feature for those who were already using it.

It is important to note that the current court ruling does not mean that the British security services have already gained access to all encrypted iCloud data. The exact terms of the order, the technical means of its implementation and the relevant legal restrictions remain under consideration.

What the British Government and human rights campaigners have said

The British Government insists that citizens’ right to privacy must be protected, but that it must not hinder efforts to ensure public safety.

A spokesperson for the Ministry of the Interior explained to Reuters that Apple has been cooperating with the police and intelligence services in accordance with the law for many years. According to the government’s position, the new directive requires that the necessary technical capabilities for such cooperation be maintained.

At the same time, the human rights organisations Privacy International and Liberty believe that secret demands placed on technology companies could undermine the privacy of millions of people.

They also emphasise that deliberately weakening encryption mechanisms could pose risks not only through government access, but also through the potential exploitation of vulnerabilities by malicious actors.

Akiko Hart, Director of Liberty, described the court’s ruling as a victory for transparency. Human rights campaigners believe that the public should be aware of government decisions that may affect the security of personal data.

When will the court consider the legality of the order concerning Apple?

Apple lodged a new appeal against the government’s demand in July 2026. At the same time, human rights organisations are challenging the legality and secrecy of the TCN mechanism itself.

The ruling of 19 November relates solely to the possibility of officially confirming the existence of the order. The court has not yet determined whether it complies with the law or whether the government can require Apple to make changes to its data protection systems.

The main hearing in the case is expected to take place in 2027. The court will determine separately which details of the government order can be disclosed publicly without compromising national security.

As things stand on 19 November, the existence of the order has been officially confirmed, but its legality remains unresolved. Apple is continuing its legal challenge, and the ultimate implications for the data protection of British iCloud users will depend on the tribunal’s future rulings.

WRITE A REPLY

enter your comment!
enter your name here